
session early afternoon at the Majestic Bastille. Twelve spectators in the hall. After 10 minutes of film, a first person leaves. A half-hour a second escape quietly. The third gives little early. If we calculate well, 25% of spectators I'm a No Man's Land have therefore left the meeting before its end. First assessment to be learned: the movie does not leave indifferent. At best, it causes ... At worst, it irritates.
In fact, there are two ways to approach I'm a No Man's Land . Either by saying we will see Philippe Katerine clowning or engineering as his artistic taste. Is wondering how Thierry Jousse , former editor of Cahiers du Cinema (1991-1996), will assume the legacy of the New Wave or that of any single critic who tries to achieve (its The first feature we missed invisible when its release).
Proponents of the first approach, which emphasizes a whimsical, if not completely blocked is Philippe Katerine opportunity for parodying his own role (that of a singer who dresses like a drag queen on acid) may be disappointed. It is difficult to assume the status of an actor facing a camera when he's not a clip. Katerine plays like a banana. Facial expressions of amazement, staggered response, no change of tone, expression almost static. Yet well surrounded by Julie Depardieu , Aurore Clement and Jackie Berroyer , nothing works. Evil is very contagious, everyone ends up over-play. The responsibility for this failure may be dependent on the director and his direction of actors. Which brings us to the second approach to this film. How it is out Thierry Jousse after spending thousands of hours to watch films and write hundreds of papers on the latter sometimes being excessively partisan and arrogant. Well ... it is almost independent of our will to say but we must recognize that no talent for telling a story in pictures. It's extremely ugly plastically. No research design, a hideous photograph, a succession of close-ups ridiculous, some natural signs unnecessary conventional framings. Looks like the theater played poorly and badly filmed. It's pretty painful to watch. Hence the departure of 25% of spectators.
0 comments:
Post a Comment